CALL US NOW

Long Island Sex Crimes Defense Attorneys

Discreet, Aggressive Defense When Everything Is on the Line

Few criminal allegations carry the stigma, and the life-altering consequences, of a sex crime charge. Beyond potential incarceration, a conviction under New York’s Penal Law Article 130 can trigger mandatory sex offender registration under the Sex Offender Registration Act (SORA), affecting where you can live, work, and travel — often for decades or life. MontanaroLaw P.C. handles these cases with the discretion and intensity they demand for clients throughout Nassau and Suffolk County.

Charges We Defend

  • Sexual Abuse (Penal Law §§ 130.55, 130.60, 130.65): Ranges from a Class B misdemeanor to a Class D felony depending on the victim’s age, the use of forcible compulsion, or whether the victim was physically helpless or mentally incapacitated at the time.
  • Rape (Penal Law §§ 130.25, 130.30, 130.35): New York recognizes three degrees. First-degree rape is a Class B violent felony and typically involves forcible compulsion, a victim under 11, or a victim who is physically helpless. Second- and third-degree rape involve age-based consent issues, including cases where the age gap between the parties is a central legal question.
  • Sexual Battery / Criminal Sexual Act: New York’s equivalent charge for oral or anal sexual conduct, mirroring the degree structure and penalties of the rape statutes.
  • Lower-level but still serious charges, often arising from contact allegations in public places, workplaces, or social settings, and frequently the first charge filed while police continue investigating.
  • Forcible Touching and Sexual Misconduct (Penal Law §§ 130.20, 130.52): Lower-level but still serious charges, often arising from contact allegations in public places, workplaces, or social settings, and frequently the first charge filed while police continue investigating.
  • Possession or Promotion of a Sexual Performance by a Child Covers alleged possession, distribution, or promotion of child sexual abuse material. These cases increasingly originate from federal ICAC (Internet Crimes Against Children) task force investigations and can trigger parallel state and federal exposure.
  • Failure to Register or Verify Under SORAA (Correction Law § 168-t): separate criminal charge for registrants who miss an address update or verification deadline — distinct from the underlying sex offense conviction.

Understanding SORA Risk Level Hearings

A conviction that requires registration triggers a separate SORA risk-level hearing, where the court assigns a risk level (1, 2, or 3) that determines the duration and public visibility of registration. This hearing is a critical, and often underappreciated, part of the case — the difference between a Level 1 and Level 3 designation can shape someone’s life for years after sentencing.

SORA Risk Levels Explained

  • Level 1 (Low Risk): Registration for a minimum of 20 years; information is not published on the public registry website, only available to law enforcement and certain agencies.
  • Level 2 (Moderate Risk): Registration for life (with a petition option after 30 years in some cases); listed on the public registry with photo and address.
  • Level 3 (High Risk): Registration for life with no reduction petition available; subject to community notification and the most restrictive residency rules.The risk level is determined using a point-based instrument that weighs factors like the relationship to the victim, use of violence, and criminal history — and it is litigated at a hearing separate from the underlying criminal case. An attorney who prepares specifically for this hearing, rather than treating it as a formality, can meaningfully change the outcome.

Why Early Representation Is Critical

Sex crime investigations often begin quietly, sometimes with a forensic interview or a request to “just talk” with police before any charge is filed. Statements made during this stage, without counsel, frequently become the centerpiece of the prosecution’s case. MontanaroLaw P.C. urges anyone who learns they are under investigation to consult an attorney immediately, before speaking with law enforcement.

How a Sex Crimes Case Moves Through the System

Sex crime cases in Nassau and Suffolk County typically follow a predictable path, and the earliest stages often decide the outcome.

  • Investigation. Many cases begin before any arrest — a Child Advocacy Center forensic interview, a request from a detective to “come in and clear things up,” or a wiretap consent call arranged by police. Nothing said during this phase is off the record, and there is no requirement to participate without an attorney present.
  • Arrest and Arraignment. Once charged, a defendant is arraigned before a judge who sets bail or release conditions. In felony sex offense cases, courts frequently impose an order of protection at this stage, which can affect where you can live and whether you can see your own children.
  • Grand Jury and Indictment. Felony sex crimes in New York must be presented to a grand jury before proceeding to a felony trial. This is a critical window for defense counsel to request evidence, challenge the sufficiency of the case, and in some circumstances present exculpatory testimony.
  • Pre-Trial Motions and Discovery. New York’s discovery reform laws require prosecutors to turn over evidence, including forensic reports, medical exams, and prior statements by the complainant, on a strict timeline. Missed deadlines can result in dismissal or suppression — an area we scrutinize closely in every case.
  • Trial or Negotiated Resolution. Some cases resolve through negotiated pleas to reduced, non-registerable offenses where the facts support it. Others proceed to trial, where cross-examination of forensic and medical evidence is often central to the defense.
  • Sentencing and the SORA Hearing. If a conviction results in a registerable offense, a separate SORA hearing determines the risk level (1, 2, or 3), which controls how long registration lasts and how much information about the registrant is made public.

Our Approach

We conduct an independent investigation into the allegations, scrutinize the reliability of forensic evidence and witness statements, and work to protect our clients’ rights and reputations at every stage — from pre-charge investigation through trial, and, where a conviction results, through the SORA hearing and any appeal.

Serving Nassau and Suffolk County

MontanaroLaw P.C. represents clients facing sex crime charges in courts throughout Long Island, including Nassau County District Court, Nassau County Court – Mineola, Suffolk County District Court, Suffolk County Court – Riverhead and local town and village courts. See our full County Court Directory →

If you are also facing related charges, see our pages on Domestic Violence Defense and Assault Defense, or return to our Criminal Defense overview.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need a lawyer before I talk to the police? Yes. Anything said during an initial interview, forensic interview, or “just to clear things up” conversation can be used against you, even before charges are filed. Speak with an attorney before making any statement.

Is every sex crime a felony in New York? No. Charges like forcible touching or third-degree sexual abuse can be misdemeanors, while rape, criminal sexual act, and aggravated cases are felonies. The classification depends heavily on the specific facts, including the alleged victim’s age and any use of force.

What triggers federal jurisdiction in a sex crime case? Federal charges typically arise when the alleged conduct crosses state lines, involves the internet (such as CSAM cases investigated by ICAC task forces or the FBI), or occurs on federal property. Federal sentencing guidelines are generally more severe than New York State penalties.

Can a sex crime charge be sealed or expunged in New York? Registerable sex offenses generally cannot be sealed under New York’s sealing statute, even for otherwise-eligible convictions. This makes fighting the charge, or negotiating a non-registerable resolution, especially important.

How long does sex offender registration last? It depends on the SORA risk level assigned at sentencing: 20 years minimum for Level 1, and lifetime registration for Level 2 and Level 3, with limited petition options in some Level 2 cases after 30 years.

What is a SORA risk-level hearing? It’s a separate court proceeding, held after conviction, where the judge assigns a risk level using a point-based instrument. This hearing determines how long you register and whether your information appears on the public registry.

What should I do if I learn I’m under investigation but haven’t been charged? Contact an attorney immediately. Pre-charge representation can include communicating with detectives on your behalf, preparing you for or advising against a forensic interview, and in some cases resolving the matter before formal charges are ever filed.

How much does a sex crimes defense attorney cost in Nassau or Suffolk County? Fees vary based on case complexity, whether the charge is a misdemeanor or felony, and whether the case is likely to go to trial. MontanaroLaw P.C. offers a free, confidential case evaluation to discuss your specific situation and fee structure.

Contact MontanaroLaw P.C.

These cases require immediate, confidential attention. Call (516)-203-1700 to speak privately with a Long Island sex crimes defense attorney.